The two theories of ethics and their styles of reasoning brought forth a new understanding of my decision-making processes and biases. Although they are contradictory, I find these two theories to complement one another, and both play a role in our ethical reasoning. According to LaFollette, "consequentialists claim we are morally obligated to act in ways that produce the best consequences.Consequentialism, at times, uses rules to help decipher the weight of one consequence over another. Conversely, deontology is the idea that we are obligated to follow moral rules regardless of the consequences. (Lafollette, 2007). A consequentialist would consider available actions, trace the likely consequences of each for all affected, and then take action with the best overall consequence" (p. 23). When I think about a consequentialist, I think about a person who is trying to make the best decisions regardless of the outcome. (LaFollette, 2007).
According to consequentialism, before choosing how to behave, we are obligated to think through every possible scenario or consequence, weight them and select the option that has the best outcome for everyone. The most prominent example of consequentialism is about the moral rightness of acts, which holds that whether an action is morally right depends only on the consequences of that act or of something related to that act, such as the motive behind the act or a general rule requiring acts of the same kind (Stanford, 2003).
Deontology is primarily a list of rules of do not's. How
“we should act in ways circumscribed by moral rules or rights, and that these
rules or rights are at least partly independent of consequences” (LaFollette,
2007, p. 22).
Of course these were all helpful when we were young because of our moral decisions, which were of little consequence because of our age. ). Making
decisions with this approach bases actions on established moral imperatives so
choices are a bit more restrictive.
The central question in each of these theories focuses on what you should do, rather than what you want to do.
Deontology and consequentialism differ because deontology deals with morals, regardless of whether or not the outcome is favorable. In contrast, consequentialism seeks to satisfy most people and define the morality of the situation. I think the consequential and deontologist theory has value, depending on the situation. When making work-related decisions, I tend to lean toward the consequentialist theory because I must do what is best for all employees across five departments. When reflecting, I've often been accused of being a consequentialist. As a leader, I believe you have to be mindful of which approach you use to ensure that you do not use laws to be insensitive to others. Having an awareness and considering other's actions and opinions is a consideration and is respectful in situations.
References:
LaFollette, H. (2007). The Practice of Ethics. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. (2003). Consequentialism. Plato.stanford.edu. Retrieved from https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/consequentialism/


No comments:
Post a Comment